After winning the World Series just two years ago, the Chicago White Sox have been a huge disappointment at 72-90 on the year. Injuries and underachievement did them in. The pitching has faltered somewhat the past two years, and GM Ken Williams has begun dismantling this rotation. He’s done a pretty good job of loading up on young arms, it’s just a matter of when these guys will be ready. From the looks of it, the White Sox need them to be ready NOW.
The White Sox have some big holes to fill up the middle, at 2B, SS and CF. With the team salary sitting at $109M right now, and Mark Buehrle due a $5M raise this season, look for the Sox to try and move at least one expensive part this off-season. The most obvious targets would be Javier Vazquez ($11.5M per through 2010), Jon Garland ($12M in 2008, his last year) and Jose Contreras ($10M in 2008 and 2009, ouch). Good luck moving Contreras at that price point. Williams has had a lot of interest in Garland, but he has been asking way too much considering that Garland will make $12M and has just one year left on his contract. Vazquez had a pretty good season, and interest in him should be high, but he holds a limited no-trade clause which allows him to block moves to 9 teams in the AL West or the NL West.
Offense
It wasn’t just the pitching that doomed the Sox in 2007. Their offense finished dead last in the AL with just 693 runs scored. They batted just .246 as a team and weren’t patient. Some of their biggest run producers slumped at the same time, with 1B Paul Konerko and RF Jermaine Dye both having bad years. They lost starting 3B Joe Crede early in the season, and DH Jim Thome missed some time, which didn’t help things. They did slug 190 HR, second in the AL, but it wasn’t enough to overcome their deficiencies. With a little bit of retooling, they could rebound in a big way in 2008.
C: A.J. Pierzynski (.263/.309/.403 with 14 HR and 50 RBI in 472 AB)
Toby Hall (.207/.225/.241 with 3 RBI in 116 AB)
An above-average hitting catcher, Pierzynski was one of the regulars with a down year. He just re-signed for 3 more years, so will be a mainstay in Chicago for some time. Hall is a good backup.
1B: Paul Konerko (.259/.351/.490 with 31 HR and 90 RBI in 549 AB)
Konerko was in a season-long slump, and for the Sox to contend, they need him to be better. He’s locked in long-term, and I expect for him to rebound some next season.
2B: Danny Richar (.230/.289/.406 with 6 HR and 15 RBI in 187 AB)
Tadahito Iguchi (.251/.340/.382 with 6 HR and 31 RBI in 327 AB)
Since they moved Iguchi at the trading deadline, this is a huge area of need for the White Sox. They will sign one of the free agents out there or trade for a starter, because Richar is not ready.
SS: Juan Uribe (.234/.284/.394 with 20 HR and 68 RBI in 513 AB)
That is a lot of at-bats to be giving a guy with a .678 OPS. Thankfully, the 28-year old Uribe’s contract is over, and I do not see Williams exercising his team option on him. I would trade for a shortstop, maybe a Clint Barmes or somebody.
3B: Joe Crede (.216/.258/.317 with 4 HR and 22 RBI in 167 AB)
Josh Fields (.244/.308/.480 with 23 HR and 67 RBI in 373 AB)
With Crede locked in long-term, I would expect the Sox to either move Fields into left field for next season, or move him to another team. Fields could be a much better hitter if he focused less on power.
RF: Jermaine Dye (.254/.317/.486 with 28 HR and 78 RBI in 508 AB)
A lousy first half was redeemed by a .298/.368/.579 second half, and Chicago has him for two more years.
CF: Jerry Owens (.267/.324/.312 with 1 HR and 17 RBI in 356 AB)
Owens should in no way be a starter in the majors. 12 XBH in that many AB is just embarrassing; he’s Podsednik lite, if that’s possible. His speed and defense suit him perfectly as a fourth outfielder, so look for the Sox to play for a short-term centerfielder this winter. They don’t have much salary wiggle room, so they will have to trade somebody. If Andruw Jones would sign a one-year deal, he’d be a great match here, with Ryan Sweeney coming up through the farm system.
LF: Josh Fields (see above)
Scott Podsednik (.243/.299/.369 with 2 HR and 11 RBI in 214 AB)
Chicago should trade Podsednik, who is eligible for salary arbitration this offseason (he will make just over $3M next year), and pick up one of the pieces they need.
DH: Jim Thome (.275/.410/.563 with 35 HR and 96 RBI in 432 AB)
His .275 average led the team, if you don’t count backup Rob Mackowiak’s .278. The White Sox need him to step up big if they are to compete next season.
1B/OF: Darin Erstad (.248/.310/.335 with 4 HR and 32 RBI in 310 AB)
There is no way the team should exercise their $3.5M option on him. Luis Terrero can be a fine backup.
This lineup should do a lot better next season without touching a thing. That being said, there are no starters at 2B, SS or in CF, and that will be a huge headache for Chicago entering this offseason. They should target one key acquisition and just fill the other two spots with stopgaps. I know Miguel Tejada wants to play out west, but could Chicago be a possible fit?
Pitching
Chicago’s staff was ranked 12th in the AL in ERA, with a 4.77 team mark. They had decent walk and strikeout numbers, but they just allowed a lot of hits and a lot of runs. The young bullpen blew a lot of saves. Their overall performance suggests that the White Sox staff suffered a bit of bad luck, and should do better next year.
Rotation: Mark Buehrle, Javier Vazquez, Jon Garland, Jose Contreras, John Danks
The rotation is actually pretty good (they had 88 quality starts this year, 4th in the AL, and had 9 complete game shutouts, the same as Cleveland), but the front four as listed here would make almost $50M in 2008, and this is no $50M rotation. Like I said, expect one or two of these middle 3 guys to be gone, and the 5th slot can be filled by Gavin Floyd, Lance Broadway, or a number of other youngsters.
Bullpen: Matt Thornton, Boone Logan, Ryan Bukvich, Mike MacDougal, Mike Myers
This bullpen features a lot of potential. Thornton is a good long man, and Logan and Bukvich are decent fillers. MacDougal is capable of so much more, but he doesn’t seem to have his head on right. Ken Williams is bringing Mike Myers back, though with Thornton and Logan also being lefties, I have no idea why. Sisco is an intriguing lefty (he’s 6′ 10″) that Williams positively stole from Kansas City, and Aardsma can strike people out. The Sox need to bring in one veteran setup man for this pen to work.
Closer: Bobby Jenks
Jenks has been pretty consistent for the Sox, and really turned it on late, posting a 2.15 ERA with 20 saves after the All-Star break. He only walked one batter in the whole second half!
Defense
Chicago had the third most errors in the AL this year, and could stand to improve in this area. Konerko and Owens are good defensively, and Dye is pretty solid, if he lacks some range. A lot rides on who they get to fill the open positions up the middle. Getting Crede back next season will help a lot too.
On the farm
CF: Ryan Sweeney (.289/.351/.401 in 5 minor league seasons)
The Sox have tried to give the centerfielder job to Brian Anderson the past two seasons, but that hasn’t worked out too well. At 22 years old, Sweeney is the most toolsy hitter the Sox have, plays great defense, and should be ready pretty soon.
SP: Lance Broadway (17-20 with a 3.82 ERA and 6.88 K/9 in 3 minor league seasons)
Broadway is not a real flamethrower, but he’s competing well at triple-A for a 23-year old. This righty had a September callup and impressed people with his big curveball, so with some work on his control, he may have a shot sometime in 2008.
SP: Charles Haeger (36-43 with a 3.78 ERA and 6.32 K/9 in 6 minor league seasons)
Haeger is one of those rare pitchers who regularly throws a knuckleball. He also has a fastball and a “slurve” that he can throw as contrast pitches. Like most knuckleballers, he’s not dominant, but he could be a steady option in the rotation if needed.